Cummings concludes successful tenure leading Cushwa Center for the Study of American Catholicism; Dochuk and Lantigua to become co-directors

Author: Beth Staples

Kathleen Sprows Cummings Headshot
Kathleen Sprows Cummings

American studies and history professor Kathleen Sprows Cummings, who has led the Cushwa Center for the Study of American Catholicism for the past 11 years, will step down from the position in June, with Notre Dame historian Darren Dochuk and theologian David Lantigua becoming co-directors.

Cummings, the Rev. John A. O'Brien College Professor of History, has been associated with the center for nearly 30 years, starting when she arrived at the University as a doctoral student in history.

“It’s hard to overstate the importance of the Cushwa Center in my academic life; it’s been larger than any other institution,” said Cummings, who served as its associate director from 2001 to 2012. “I planned just to stay a couple of years and move on to somewhere else, but it was just a great place to be.”

Cummings credits Cushwa founding director Jay P. Dolan as being instrumental in her development as a historian and scholar.

“I remember as a Ph.D. student saying to him that not enough had been written about women in the Catholic Church, and he said, ‘You’re right. You do it.’” 

And that she has, including her 2010 book New Women of the Old Faith: Gender and American Catholic Identity in the Progressive Era, which won three Catholic Press Association Awards. She’s also written numerous journal articles and reviews centered on women and faith.

Kathy Cummings Phd Commencement
Cummings, who earned her Ph.D. in history, preparing to be hooded by Cushwa founding director Jay P. Dolan at Commencement in 1999.

Foregrounding the study of Catholic women — and women religious, in particular — was one of Cummings’ goals in her time as the William W. and Anna Jean Cushwa Director. Since 2012, the center has hosted the Conference on the History of Women Religious, which helps historians to learn about and preserve the record of vowed women since the Middle Ages and to integrate their stories into larger narratives.

Under her leadership, Cushwa also established a grant program for scholars focusing on the study of Catholic women with support from a gift from Anita Tiberi McMahon. In 2015, Cummings convened “The Nun and the World: Catholic Sisters and the Second Vatican Council,” an international conference at Notre Dame’s London Global Gateway. And from 2020 to 2022, she led a project called “Gender, Sex, and Power: Towards a History of Clergy Sex Abuse in the U.S. Catholic Church,” which culminated in an in-person research symposium.

“Kathy’s expertise, dedication, and enthusiasm have strengthened the Cushwa Center in so many ways and meant a great deal to people around the country and world who study Catholicism,” said Sarah Mustillo, the I.A. O’Shaughnessy Dean of the College of Arts and Letters. “And now, I look forward to seeing how Darren and David will shepherd and advance the work being done at Cushwa.” 

A marshaling of perspectives

Dochuk, the Andrew V. Tackes College Professor of History, and Lantigua, an associate professor in the Department of Theology, lauded Cummings’ vision and contributions and said they’re honored to continue Cushwa’s vitally important work.

Darren Dochuk Interview
Darren Dochuk

Dochuk’s expertise and experience includes U.S. religious history, energy, and the environment.

“At all levels, from Rome to the grassroots, Catholics and the Catholic Church have sought to address social and environmental challenges wrought by energy dependencies through a marshaling of moral, theological, and humanities perspectives,” said the co-executive editor of the journal Modern American History, which is currently based at Notre Dame.

“I look forward to helping place the Cushwa Center at the heart of those ongoing conversations, and to making the historical study of Catholicism and American religion — Cushwa’s forte — relevant for clearer understanding of current climate-related circumstances.”

Lantigua’s research focuses on Catholicism in the colonial history of the Americas and the theology and social thought of Pope Francis, the first Hispanic pope from the global South. 

“By anchoring the study of American Catholicism in historical and theological inquiry, I hope to preserve and strengthen the Center’s ongoing intellectual contribution to academia and the broader Church on critical issues of the past and present,” said Lantigua, who co-directs the Catholic social tradition minor and is a faculty fellow of the Kellogg Institute for International Studies and the Institute for Latino Studies.

David Lantigua
David Lantigua

With Latin America as the most populous region of Catholicism in the world, and the growing demographic of U.S. Latino Catholics, Lantigua said the optics of American Catholicism are shifting in fascinating ways. He wants to make that reality visible. 

“In addition to the U.S. Hispanic Catholic population, there are also ethnic traditions of American Catholicism among African/African American, Asian, and Indigenous American populations, and their historical presence raises acute questions surrounding pluralism, racism, and migration,” he said.

Dochuk welcomes the chance to connect Cushwa with other units on campus and centers beyond Notre Dame’s borders that are animated by similar questions about the nature of Catholicism and faith in the modern world — particularly along fresh lines of inquiry at the intersections of religion, energy, sustainability, social action, and environment. 

“This is a dizzying world of change,” said Dochuk. “I am excited to see the Cushwa Center operate as an anchor of sorts, with programming and the provision of historically grounded and faith-informed knowledge geared to a rich plethora of social interests and concerns, scholarly methods and spirits of action.”

‘An excellent trajectory’

The first four directors of Cushwa (from left, Timothy Matovina, R. Scott Appleby, Kathleen Cummings, and Jay Dolan) at a 40th anniversary celebration for the center in 2015.

Throughout her time as director, Cummings has kept the center in the spotlight through her public commentary in a variety of media outlets. After Pope Benedict XVI resigned in 2013, Cummings provided insights and historical context on NBC and MSNBC, then frequently offered on-air perspective as Pope Francis was elected and continued to make news.

The opening of Notre Dame’s Rome Global Gateway also catalyzed another of Cummings’ goals as Cushwa director: studying Catholicism around the world in order to better understand Catholicism in the U.S. In 2014, she and historian John McGreevy, then dean of the College of Arts and Letters and now the Charles and Jill Fischer Provost, coordinated “American Catholicism in a World Made Small,” the first seminar held at the site.

Next year, Cummings will be on sabbatical, continuing her research in Boston and Rome on the history of the clergy sex abuse scandal, and studying the history of Catholic sisters in Rome. The 2021 Sheedy Excellence in Teaching Award winner also will develop a course on global Catholicism with the Rev. Paul Kollman, C.S.C., associate professor of theology.

In a letter she posted reflecting on her time at the center, Cummings thanks a number of people, including the three prior directors — Dolan, now-Keough School of Global Affairs Dean R. Scott Appleby, and now-Department of Theology Chair Timothy Matovina.

“I'm gratified to have been able to build on an excellent foundation,” she said, “and to have added my own stamp on Cushwa.”